What The Critics Said

'The book is really gripping and her research is first rate and truly evocative of the 1860s and I found it intensely interesting. Well recommended.'

Eurocrime

'I’ve followed and enjoyed this series for years, and applaud Ms Knight’s decision to write about Faro’s early years in the force. There aren’t many novels set on Orkney in the 1860s either...A well-loved series [and] there is always something to enjoy. Read this one for the characters, the setting or the ambience rather than the plot.'

My Shelf

‘A good solid world of historical detective fiction, providing plenty of action and plot twists to keep the reader interested. There is a good sense of time and place, with the Orkney Islands and people being particularly well realized…well-written and satisfying... It can be easily read by anyone unacquainted with the other Faro novels and assumes no previous knowledge of the character or his exploits... All-in-all a very enjoyable read.’

Historical Novels Review

'It is fascinating to find a detective novel set against the unusual backdrop of Orkney in 1861...What emerges is a thoroughly enjoyable mystery whose pace is perfectly judged to keep you turning the page. En route to the book's violent conclusion you learn more about Faro's early life and his background, and some of the influences that made him the man so well known to readers of the other books in the series.'

Undiscovered Scotland